Quite honestly, if this dessert recipe did not have Paula Wolfert's name attached to it, I probably would not have gone near it, because it does seem unlikely. I have had such good luck with her carefully researched, yet personally inspired food in the past, that I decided to give it a try. And I did have a butternut squash lying around, which was beginning to worry me, age-wise. So I took a shot at this Turkish sweet, which features an unusual, but uncomplicated preparation. I fooled around with it slightly, but not enough to actually complicate matters. It's pretty good, I think. It is also one of those dishes in which the ingedients behave a little strangely, and which tastes more complicated than it is. I take considerable pleasure in this sort of food entertainment.
All you need to make this is a butternut squash, a cup of sugar, some walnuts and some butter. First, you peel and cube the squash, and put it in a ceramic baking dish-shallow, rather than deep, and mix it with the sugar. You then leave it out, and the squash begins to "sweat", while the sugar liquifies. This will take at least half an hour-possibly longer. I do not know how long mine took, as the time included an unplanned nap-which was definitely over 1/2 hour. It was ready when I woke up.
While you wait and/or nap, you preheat your oven to 300F, and set the squash seeds in it, sprinkled with a bit more sugar,and perhaps a little cinnamon, on a scrap of aluminum foil, to dry out and toast. (This business with the squash seeds is my own meddling-I can't bear to throw them out, ever since I discovered how wonderful they are, spiced and toasted, and scattered over my squash soup. I think they worked out rather well here, too-but of course you can forget about them if you like.)
Give the squash a stir,gently, with a wooden spoon, and cover it with crumpled, dampened parchment paper. Set it in the oven for about 1 1/2 hours, then turn the oven off, and let the oven and squash cool down together. It reabsorbs a good bit of it's own syrup as it cools slowly. Store it somewhere cool until ready to serve. Then, melt a tsp of butter,in a small saucepan, and toast a handful of walnuts, along with the squash seeds. Serve the squash with a glop of creme fraiche, yogurt, or sour cream, and the toasted nuts.
This tastes a bit exotic, but also a bit like pumpkin pie. (And that's before you add the seeds with cinnamon.) It makes a nice, not too heavy ending to a Middle Eastern sort of meal. The recipe would serve about 3 people, I think, with toppings.
Your recipe sounds wonderful. It is on my list now. Thank you.
Posted by: Fran | February 26, 2006 at 01:06 PM
This sounds delicious, exotic and very healthy. I've always thrown away squash seeds; it never occurred to me to roast them. Do you eat them shells and all?
Posted by: Tania | February 26, 2006 at 10:55 PM
I've been carrying around a newspaper clipping with a similar recipe for years. I finally tried your recipe yesterday and served it over vanilla ice cream (I would have preferred goat yogurt or the fabulous goat vanilla ice cream I discovered recently, but the goats are busy having kids and it's hard to find goat products now). My husband and I thought the squash was fantastic. I did guild the lilly a bit by adding some sliced kumquats (thank you, Amanda Hesser!). Years ago I made a pumpkin pie like an apple pie with sliced pumpkin and it was fantastic. The second time I made one the pumpkin was not soft by the time the crust was done, so I've not repeated it. My next project with the leftover butternut squash is to make it into watermelon rind-like chutney. I'll let you know how it turns out.
Posted by: Lynn D. | March 04, 2006 at 11:49 AM
Lynn-I'm glad you liked it, and the kumquat idea sounds excellent.
You will probably not be surprised when I tell you that I am crazy about goat milk yogurt, too. But icecream! It must be amazing-I am terribly jealous about the icecream.
I seem to recall that in one of the Laura Ingalls Wilder books, the ever inventive "Ma" made an "apple" pie from a green , unripe pumpkin, and no one could guess what it was. Perhaps very thinly sliced butternut sqush would soften faster than pumpkin? I like the sound of your pie- hope you don't give up on it permanently.
Looking forward to hearing about the chutney project.
Posted by: lindy | March 04, 2006 at 02:47 PM
Butternut squash dessert? That IS a new one. I'm gonna have to try this :)
Posted by: Shammi | March 07, 2006 at 07:36 AM
Hi Shammi- Yes, it's a strange one alright...but it doesn't taste strange, surprisingly.Next time I'm going to try Lynn's kumquat idea, if there are any available.
Posted by: lindy | March 08, 2006 at 08:00 AM